How to talk to a student you think used AI

How do I talk to a student I suspect used AI, without accusing them? Ask the student to tell you how they made the work, in a private talk with enough time, and wait until you have heard their answer before you form a view. Before that talk, check what your doubt is based on, because a checker’s result or a feeling from reading tells you where to look in the work but does not tell you who wrote it. In the talk itself, start with questions about the work and leave any score out of the first part of the conversation.

Before you talk: what you have and what you do not

If you ran the essay through an AI checker, what you have now is an estimate of how much the writing looks like the text that AI tools produce, and nothing about who wrote the essay or how the work was done. Some checkers also mark the passages that had the most weight in the result, which is useful, since it shows you which paragraphs to read again more slowly before you say anything.

If you did not use a checker and only had a feeling while reading, you are in much the same position: a feeling is a starting point, and it can be right or wrong.

Neither a checker nor your own reading can tell you whether the student meant to deceive you. The student may have written the text in their first language and used a translator, accepted the changes a grammar corrector suggested, or used a tool that they believed the course allowed, and in each case the text can look much the same. Whether a rule was broken depends on what your course and your school allow and on what you told the class about AI use when you set the task. A result is a signal and not proof, and the decision is made by a person: in this case by you, after you have listened to the student.

Before you contact the student, write down what made you doubt the work, for example a particular passage, a source you could not find, or a clear difference from the student’s earlier essays. Read the rules on AI use that applied to this task again, and keep a copy of the task sheet with your notes. It also helps to have the student’s earlier work in front of you so that you can compare the two. If the matter goes further, these notes will show what your doubt was based on from the start.

Reasons to look closer, and reasons that are not

Some doubts can be checked. The work may be far from what this student writes in class: longer sentences, words you have never seen them use, much more detail than before. It may skip every reading and example from your lessons, or answer a question close to yours that you did not ask. The references are often the quickest thing to test, so pick a few and look them up. If a quote cannot be found anywhere, or a real book does not say what the essay says it does, you have something specific to ask about, and the student can explain it or not.

Suppose the essay that worried you is simply very clean: no spelling mistakes, a formal tone, an introduction, a main part and an ending. None of that is a good reason on its own. Writing well is not suspicious, and many students check their work several times or use a corrector that the course allows. Academic work asks for a formal tone, and a tidy, formal text can look like AI writing at first sight even if no AI was used. As for the plan of the essay, your own task sheet may have asked for exactly that. If the student writes in a second language, an even and careful style is normal too, as the section on this below explains. A high result from a checker belongs here as well when there is nothing else beside it: it can help you decide where to look, but it is not enough to decide anything.

Go through your notes once more with this in mind. If every reason on them is of this second kind, think again before you ask the student for a talk. One reason you can check is enough to make a talk a fair next step, provided you go in with a real question and are ready for the answer to change your view.

How to set up the talk

Choose a place where nobody else can hear and a time when neither of you has to leave soon. A word in the corridor after class, with other students walking past, makes almost anyone defensive. The message that asks for the talk can be short: you would like to hear how they prepared the latest piece of work. Do not put your doubt in that message. You have not heard their side yet.

Open with the work. Ask where they started, which sources they used and how they found them, what was hardest, and what they changed along the way. People who wrote a text can usually talk about it in some detail. They remember why they picked an example, what they meant by a term, which paragraph took longest. After that, turn to one of the passages from your notes and ask the student to explain it in their own words. Some students explain badly when they are nervous, so one shaky answer should not decide anything.

Words you can adapt to your own way of speaking:

  • How did you prepare this piece of work, from the first step to the finished text?
  • Can you tell me in your own words what you meant in this paragraph?
  • Do you still have drafts, notes or the sources you used?
  • Did you use any tool while writing, such as a corrector, a translator or an AI chat?

When you ask about drafts, say why you are asking: you want to understand how the work grew. Many writing programs keep a version history with earlier states of a file, and it can show the text building up over several days, sometimes much longer. A notebook, a list of sources or a rough outline can show the same. Many people write in one file and never keep earlier versions, so if the student has none, that proves nothing.

Keep the score out of the opening minutes. A number said at the start sounds like a verdict, and the student then spends the rest of the talk arguing against it. If you used a checker, give it one job in the room: pointing you to the passages you ask about. On ScanForAI you can paste the work into the scanner, read any passages it marks and the confidence line, and turn each passage into an open question, such as how that paragraph was written; our page for teachers explains this way of working. The result gives your questions a place to start. What you decide afterwards comes from you.

The student may say something you did not expect. A tutor helped, and the course allows that. A translator was used for one hard paragraph. They read the rule differently from the way you meant it. If they tell you they used an AI tool, thank them for being open, ask which parts and how, and compare that with the rules for this task. If the rules allowed it, there is nothing to solve. If they did not, the matter may move to the next step of your school’s process, and your notes go with it.

Straight after the talk, write down the date, what you asked and what the student said. A short note like that protects both of you if anything happens later.

Students who write in a second language

People who write in a language they learned later often use more regular sentences, patterns from their textbooks and lessons, and more formal words. AI texts have these features as well. So any checker can mark a second-language writer’s work as AI when it is not, and a teacher reading quickly can make the same mistake.

For these students it matters even more to follow the steps above with care. If you can, compare the work with something the student wrote in class, by hand or in a timed task, where you know that no tool was used, because a close match in style tells you more than any result. If your school’s rules allow it, you can also let the student explain the work in the language they know best, perhaps with a colleague who speaks that language, so that the talk is about their ideas and they do not have to explain them in English under pressure.

Correct and formal English from a student who writes in a second language is often the result of a lot of hard work, and it should never count against them. The same is true of the spelling, words and sentence habits of English as it is written in a particular country, which are not a reason for suspicion either. With these students a high result from a checker weighs even less than usual, and the talk weighs even more.

A fair process

A single fair talk helps, but fairness also depends on the steps around the talk, and those steps should be the same for every student. These are the steps we recommend:

  1. Before anyone starts writing, say which kinds of AI use the task allows and how students must say that they used them.
  2. Apply the same steps to every student, whatever their way of writing, their language or where they come from.
  3. Give the student a real chance to explain how they worked before you decide anything.
  4. Never give a grade or a penalty from a checker’s result alone. A result is not enough for either.
  5. If doubt remains after the talk, ask another person at your school for their view before you decide.
  6. If the case goes further, follow the procedure your school has set and hand over your written note of the talk.

You can also set work in ways that let you see it being written. Ask for it in stages: an outline, a first draft, the finished piece. Have the whole class write a few paragraphs in the room from time to time, so you know how each student writes before any doubt comes up. A short spoken part, where students present the work or answer a few questions on it, tells you a lot in little time. So do a few lines from each student on how they did the work and which sources and tools they used. Tasks that build on what happened in your lessons, on local examples or on the student’s own life are harder to answer with a general text. None of this needs a checker. Which of these ideas fits your subject, the size of your class and the time you have for marking?

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Can I give a grade based on a checker’s result?

No, not from any checker, ScanForAI included. A result is not enough to give a grade or to punish a student, and any checker can wrongly mark writing that a person did alone, as the section on second-language writers explains. The grade has to rest on the work, on what the student said in the talk and on your school’s rules.

What if the student has no drafts or notes?

Do not treat that as a sign of anything. Many people write straight into one document and save over it each time, so a student having no drafts proves nothing at all. You can still learn how they worked by asking them to explain the argument of the essay to you, or to tell you where they found their sources and what they used from each of them.

Should I show the student the checker’s result?

You do not have to show it, and it is better not to begin the talk with it. If the student asks why you wanted to talk, answer honestly: a checker marked some passages, those are the passages you are asking about, and the result does not decide anything. Your school’s rules may say that a student must be shown any material that is used in a case, and if they do, follow them.

What should I do if I still have doubts after the talk?

Write down which points are still unclear, and before you make any decision, ask a colleague or the person at your school who handles these cases for their opinion. The student may also be able to bring more later, such as old notes they find at home or a draft saved on another computer. And if the doubt is still there after all of this, is it really about this student’s work, or about the way the task was set?

This guide is general information for students and teachers. It is not legal advice, and your school’s own rules come first. A score from any AI checker is a signal, never proof.

Cite this guide

ScanForAI team (2026). How to talk to a student you think used AI. ScanForAI. https://scanforai.com/guides/how-to-talk-to-a-student-about-ai-use

You may share and adapt this guide if you credit ScanForAI and link to it. See Reuse and citation.

AI detection is not 100% accurate. No detector, including ScanForAI, can prove if a text was written by a person or by AI. Every result is an estimate based on writing patterns. It can be wrong in both directions. Never use it as the only reason for an important decision about a person, such as a school decision, a punishment or a hiring choice. Never use it to accuse someone.