A student’s essay was flagged as AI: what now?

For teachers and lecturers

Open the result again before you do anything else, and copy into your notes the score, the text type that was set and what the confidence line says. This comes first because a bare number grows in your head, and soon you read the essay looking for proof of it. A written note of what the result said, and did not say, keeps it at its real size. Do it even if the student came to you first and said they didn’t use AI. What counts as evidence after that is anything you could put in front of a colleague: the student’s older work, their drafts and notes, the file’s version history, and what they can tell you about the topic when you talk. A checker’s score is one more signal on that pile. You make the decision, or the people your school names do.

1. What the score says and does not say

On ScanForAI the number runs from 0 to 100. The more the essay has in common with raw AI writing (what a tool turns out before anyone edits it), the higher it goes, and it measures nothing else. It is easy to read the number as a percentage chance that AI wrote the essay, or as the share of the essay that came from a tool. It is neither of those. Keep that in mind as you look at the rest of the screen.

Human writing can score high too. It happens most often with formal or academic work that uses few short forms such as “don’t” and has sentences that all look alike, and that describes a lot of careful school writing. Students writing in English as a second language are the best-known group of human writers whom checkers wrongly flag. A high score on formal or edited human writing is a known result with a plain explanation, and it is never proof.

Then check two things that change how much the number can tell you. The first is length: treat any text under about 300 words as weak evidence, whatever the score says. The second is confidence. If the result carries a confidence line and it reads low, read that as “not enough to say”, never as a sign that a person wrote the text. A low score settles nothing either, because it means only that the text reads as human, and it cannot show how the text was made.

If you want a second look, you can scan the same text for free on ScanForAI, set the text type to match the task, read the confidence line and the marked passages, and then ask the student for drafts and an explanation. The page on what each score band means explains how to read that result. Use it to plan your questions and never to settle the case.

No checker is reliable enough to be your only reason for an accusation or a lower grade. Treat the score as one signal among several. All it should decide is what you look at next.

2. Look at the student’s other work

Start with the writing this student has already handed in to you. Work done in class, in an exam or by hand is often the most useful to compare with. Put it next to the flagged essay and read both. Compare like with like where you can. A timed piece written in a classroom will nearly always be rougher than an essay the student had weeks to revise, so roughness in the older work tells you nothing by itself.

As you read them, look for the same things in both pieces of work:

  • the words the student usually picks, and whether the flagged essay is full of words they have never used before
  • the spelling and grammar mistakes they tend to make
  • the way they build an argument and get from one point to the next
  • how they use and cite their sources
  • whether the essay answers the exact task you set or only the topic in general

A big jump in quality is worth a question, and only that. A term of practice can make a real difference to a student’s writing, and so can a tutor, a writing centre or a topic the student actually cares about. Sometimes they simply had time to revise. If English is the student’s second language, the gap can be wide: at home, with a dictionary and no clock, their writing may be far smoother than anything they produce in a timed task. AI is on that list of causes too. Note each difference, so you can ask about it later.

3. Ask for drafts and notes

Write to the student before you meet them. A few plain lines will do, for instance: “A check of your essay raised a question. Nothing has been decided. Please bring anything that shows how you worked on it when we meet.” Give them a few days. Asking in writing is fairer than catching them in the corridor, because they get time to look for their files and you both keep a copy of what was asked.

When the essay was written in Google Docs, or in Word with the file kept in OneDrive, the version history is the best thing to ask for. Saved drafts, an outline, reading notes, a source list with page numbers and photos of a plan on paper help too, as do messages about the task to a classmate or tutor. Only ask for what a student could reasonably still have. No one keeps every search they made, and asking for that would reach into their private life.

What should you expect to see? In a version history, an essay written over days usually grows in several sessions, with sentences going in, coming out and moving about. Now and then a long, finished passage turns up all at once. Ask about it, but it may have been written in a notes app or another file and pasted in, so ask where it was written and whether that file is still there.

Some students will bring nothing, and that proves nothing. Plenty of people never keep drafts, and an essay done in one evening in a single file leaves hardly any history. Write down what you got and what the student couldn’t find.

4. Talk about the topic

Hold the talk like a normal tutorial about the essay. It often tells you more than a checker can. If you open with “Did you use AI?”, you will get a yes or a no and very little else. Ask the student instead to explain the main argument the way they would to a classmate. Then go into the detail: why they picked one particular source, what a key term in the essay means, which part was hardest to write.

You can also ask how they would answer an obvious objection to their main point, or what they would change with another week. These questions are about thinking, and a student who did the thinking can usually answer them, even with rough phrasing.

Read the answers with care in both directions. Speaking and writing are different skills, and a student writing in English as a second language may explain an idea far less smoothly aloud than on the page. Nerves, time since the essay was handed in and a room with a teacher in it all make recall harder. A weak answer is therefore not proof of AI use. A clear and detailed answer, on the other hand, is real evidence that the student understands the work, and it should weigh more than the score did.

If your school asks for a second staff member at such meetings, follow that rule, and tell the student beforehand who will be there. Let them see the result that started the question if they ask. They should know what they are responding to.

5. Write down what you found

Write a short note on the same day as the meeting, while it is still fresh. Put in only facts you could show another person. Start with the task, its deadline and the essay as it was handed in. Add the score, its confidence line and the text type you chose. Then list the other work you compared the essay with, the drafts or history the student gave you, and what the student said about the topic. Keep what you saw apart from what you think it means. A paragraph of observations with one line of judgement below is easy for others to read.

You will need this note if the case goes further. A panel or a head of department may read it long after the conversation, and they cannot act on a record that rests on the score alone. Store the note and any copies of the student’s files as your school’s rules on student records require. Do not email the result or the note to colleagues who have no part in the decision.

6. When the evidence is not enough

You may reach this point still unsure: the other work fits, the drafts are thin and the conversation settled little. Then all you have is the score, and that is too little for a finding of misconduct or a lower grade. Mark the essay as you would any other, and record that the question was raised and closed. Do not lower the mark quietly to cover your doubt; the student cannot answer a doubt they were never told about.

If the drafts and the conversation do point to AI use that your rules forbid, the decision is no longer yours alone. Follow your school’s written procedure, share your note with the person it names, and make sure the student gets a fair chance to respond to everything in it.

Either way, the student is waiting, and the wait is hard on them. The next step, today if you can, is a short written message that states the outcome, the grade if there is one, and whom to contact if they disagree. Keep a copy of it with your note.

This guide is general information for students and teachers. It is not legal advice, and your school’s own rules come first. A score from any AI checker is a signal, never proof.

Cite this guide

ScanForAI team (2026). A student’s essay was flagged as AI: what now? ScanForAI. https://scanforai.com/guides/a-students-essay-scored-high-for-ai-what-next

You may share and adapt this guide if you credit ScanForAI and link to it. See Reuse and citation.

AI detection is not 100% accurate. No detector, including ScanForAI, can prove if a text was written by a person or by AI. Every result is an estimate based on writing patterns. It can be wrong in both directions. Never use it as the only reason for an important decision about a person, such as a school decision, a punishment or a hiring choice. Never use it to accuse someone.